department header

Whole Earth Seminar Winter 2004
Tuesday afternoons at 4:00pm
Natural Sciences Annex, Room 101
(Unless otherwise noted)

Please join us for tea and snacks in the E&MS Dreiss Lobby at 3:30 pm.

Seminar Coordinator: Jim Zachos
These seminars may change without advance notice. To confirm and/or to arrange for special accommodations, please call
the Earth Sciences Dept. at (831) 459-4089 or email Jennifer
Click here for maps


January 6, 2004
Global Methane Exhalations in Gaia's Breath
Keith Kvenvolden
USGS

*Co-sponsored by C.DELSI*

January 13, 2004
From Greenhouse to Icehouse; a Dinoflagellate Perspective
Henk Brinkhuis
Utrecht University

January 20, 2004
State-Space Modeling of the California Current System: SST, wind stress, upwelling thermal structure, stratification and applications to regional climate models.
Roy Mendelssohn
PFEG/NOAA

January 27, 2004
Fluid movement and mineralization in fault zones: evidence from fault diagenesis studies in Southern California
Jim Boles
UC Santa Barbara

January 27, 2004
“METER-SCALE CALCITE SPELEOTHEMS, A 100-YEAR GROWTH HISTORY FROM THE MISSION TUNNEL, SANTA BARBARA, CA
Jim Boles
UC Santa Barbara

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR FOR TUESDAY, JANUARY 27, 2004: At 12:00 NOON in E&MS, ROOM A340**

February 10, 2004
Atmospheric methane, oxygen and sulfur in the Archean/Proterozoic atmosphere
Alexander Pavlov
University of Colorado at Boulder

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*
An enhanced atmospheric greenhouse effect is required throughout the Archean and Proterozoic to offset reduced solar luminosity. The recent discovery of mass independent fractionation in sulfur isotopes in Archean sediments (Farquhar et al., 2001) but not in younger rocks provides a very strong argument in favor of an anoxic Archean atmosphere (Pavlov & Kasting, 2002). In the anoxic atmosphere CH4 should have been an important greenhouse gas because of the decreased levels of the primary oxidants - OH, O and H2O2. My photochemical simulations show that in the anoxic Archean conditions methane abundances as high as 1000 ppm can be maintained if methane production flux was somewhat close to the present day biological flux (Pavlov et al., 2001). It was demonstrated that 20 % reduced solar luminosity (~ 2.8 Gyr ago) can be offset by ~1000 ppm of methane and ~1000 ppm of CO2 (Pavlov et al., 2000), consistent with the upper limit on CO2 imposed by Rye et al, (1995). However, if the CH4/CO2 atmospheric ratio approached unity, hydrocarbon aerosols should have been formed through CH4 polymerization (Zahnle, 1986; Pavlov et al., 2001). The presence of hydrocarbon haze, or smog, would have affected the paleoenvironment in at least two important ways. Such a haze could, in principle, have shielded early biota and atmospheric gases (like NH3) from UV radiation. Organic-rich haze particles would also absorb visible radiation affecting ancient climate. After the major transition of the atmospheric oxidation state at 2.0-2.3 Gyr (“first” oxygenation event), the photochemical lifetimes of reduced atmospheric gases (like methane) should have been much shorter (and the haze should have disappeared). Therefore, a common view of the Proterozoic climate suggests that CO2 was the major greenhouse gas (along with H2O) and that atmospheric CH4 concentrations were low. Here I argue that substantial methane levels could have been present even in the Proterozoic atmosphere if O2 levels were somewhat lower than today. In agreement with earlier calculations, our 1-D photochemical model shows that the atmospheric methane mixing ratio is a highly nonlinear function of the surface methane flux. In our model, a factor of 10 increase in the methane flux results in a 60-fold increase of the surface methane concentration. 1-D climate calculations show that such a high methane abundance would keep the mean global surface temperature at ~296 K under reduced solar luminosity conditions (~17 % decreased solar luminosity at 2.3 Gyr ago), even if CO2 was present only at today’s level. Towards, the end of the Proterozoic, oceanic sulfate abundances began to increase, as indicated by measurements of trace sulfate minerals in carbonates. The corresponding increase in the abundance of sulfate-reducing bacteria and therefore increased competition for organic matter, should have led to a decrease in methane production. We propose that the first Neoproterozoic Snowball Earth episode at 750 Ma may have been triggered by a “second” rise in O2 and/or sulfate and a corresponding decrease in atmospheric CH4 to its present day values (Pavlov et al., 2003).


February 11, 2004
Linking atmospheres, space science and geology. Possible future research themes.
Alexander Pavlov
University of Colorado at Boulder

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR: Wednesday, February 11, 2004 at 1:30pm in E&MS room A340**
1) The effects of hydrodynamic escape in planetary atmospheres. Any previous photochemical calculations assumed a high (“diffusion-limited”) rate of hydrogen loss to space. If the atmosphere was anoxic, hydrogen should have been lost at a much (>100 times) slower rate (Tian et al., 2004). Hydrogen loss is extremely important for understanding the evolution of the atmospheric redox state. In hydrogen-rich atmospheres, CH4 molecules could have been effectively “recycled” after the initial photolysis and methane abundance would be high even with a small source of methane. The hydrodynamic escape of hydrogen is also important for the problem of noble gases’ abundance on the terrestrial planets. 2) Modeling of mass independent fractionation (MIF) in sulfur/oxygen isotopes. MIF in sulfur is a sensitive indicator of the atmospheric redox state. Recently, the small sulfur MIF signatures were discovered in the Antarctic ice cores. We model sulfur isotopes explicitly and try to understand the transfer of non-zero sulfur MIF to the poles during large volcanic eruptions. 3) Glaciations and Mass-Extinctions due to changes in the galactic environment. Throughout its history, the Solar system encountered a number of clouds with higher hydrogen densities 10-10000 H atoms/cm3 and will inevitably encounter them in the future. It is important to understand whether those events could cause any significant climatic impact, affect the biosphere and leave any imprint in the geological record. For future research, I propose to consider three possible mechanisms pending on the density of the colliding galactic cloud. a) Collisions with dense (>1000 H atoms/cm3) clouds (a few times in Earth history). I show that dramatic climate change can be caused by interstellar dust (from the cloud) accumulating in Earth’s atmosphere during collision. The stratospheric dust layer from such interstellar particles could provide enough radiative forcing to trigger the runaway ice-albedo feedback that results in global Snowball glaciations. b) Collisions with moderate density clouds (a few hundred times in Earth history). Moderate density clouds would not suppress the heliosphere within 1 A.U. and therefore interstellar dust would not be able to penetrate into the Earth atmosphere. However, it is very plausible that moderate density clouds would destabilize the Kuiper Belt dust orbits and huge quantities of dust would be thrown into the inner parts of the Solar system and ultimately into the Earth atmosphere. It would produce a short-term but very intensive climatic perturbation. c) Collisions with low density clouds (thousands times in Earth history). Even if the density of the local interstellar medium increases to only ~10 H/cm3, the heliosphere can be effectively suppressed within 10 A.U. due to increased external hydrogen pressure. Such events probably happened thousands of times in Earth history. Here, we show that when the heliosphere was suppressed (to 5-10 A.U.), the flux of the anomalous cosmic rays (ACR) increases dramatically into the Earth atmosphere. ACR particles are energetic, can penetrate deep into the Earth’s atmosphere and have enough energy to break N2 molecules. We calculate the production rate of NOx due to ACRs in the lower stratosphere (10-30 km) as a function of latitude and showed that it should have been orders(!) of magnitude higher in comparison with the total rate of NOx production from N2O. Using 2-D photochemical model, we evaluate how such a high NOx production rate would affect the global ozone layer.


February 17, 2004
Flexure and topography on icy satellites
Francis Nimmo
UCLA

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*
Europa's shell thickness is important in determining the satellite's astrobiological potential, dynamics and the design of future missions. Apparently flexural features on Europa may be used to infer the rigidity of the ice shell, and thus the total ice shell thickness. The thickness thus derived is ~20km, similar to independent estimates based on crater studies and tidal dissipation calculations.
Flexure does not appear to be a major cause of positive topography in bands, extensional features similar to mid-ocean ridges on Earth. Lateral shell thickness variations cannot maintain topography over geological timescales. Lateral density variations are a more likely cause of positive topography. These density variations could be caused by variations in either porosity or salt content. The latter hypothesis suggests compositional convection may be important, and could help to explain apparently diapiric surface features.


February 18, 2004
Looking forward - the origins of planetary diversity
Francis Nimmo
UCLA

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR: Wednesday, February 18, 2004 at 12:00 noon in E&MS room C332**
One of the most fundamental problems of planetary science is to explain the great diversity in solar system bodies that we observe at the present day. Here, I will present three of my research themes which help to address this question, and give specific examples which illustrate my approach.
The first theme is the use of surface observations (especially topography) to infer the present-day thermal state and evolution of planetary bodies. Characterizing these quantities is a necessary pre-requisite to explaining the divergent evolution of different bodies. Examples will be presented for the Galilean satellites, Venus and Mercury.
The second theme is the utility of magnetic field observations in inferring planetary thermal evolution. The presence of current (e.g. Mercury, Ganymede) or ancient (Moon, Mars) magnetic fields in some bodies but not others is poorly understood, but is an important clue to the manner in which these bodies have evolved.
The final theme is the importance of the process of accretion to the subsequent thermal and chemical evolution of the planets. Especially for small bodies like Mars and Mercury, initial conditions play an important role in dynamo history, melt generation and so on. The degree to which chemical equilibration occurs during large impacts determines observable isotopic signatures, and places constraints on the accretion process itself.


February 24, 2004
Obliquity-Driven Climate Change on Mars
Michael Mischna
UCLA

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

The recent discovery of vast quantities of near-subsurface water ice in both polar regions of Mars by the Mars Odyssey Gamma Ray Spectrometer has forced us to reconsider our understanding of the behavior of volatiles on Mars. These massive ice reservoirs are ubiquitous poleward of 60° in both hemispheres, both in regions where water ice is currently stable on Mars, and, more notably, where it is not. Enhanced signatures of water are also found scattered throughout the tropics and mid-latitudes. This suggests that periodic changes in Mars' orbital parameters, especially obliquity, may drive the large-scale evolution of surface volatiles on the planet. This research uses both the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Mars GCM and spacecraft observations from Mars Global Surveyor and Mars Odyssey to weave a coherent story about volatile cycling and climate change on Mars.


February 25, 2004
The Origin and Evolution of Planetary Volatiles: Where Do We Go From Here?
Michael Mischna
UCLA
*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR: Wednesday, February 25, 2004 at 12:00 noon in E&MS Room A340**
The martian surface presents a great quandary to planetary scientists. A cursory visual examination of the surface reveals that nearly the entire planet has been exposed to liquid water in the past, yet besides surface morphology, there is little additional hard evidence that liquid water was ever present on the martian surface. Such a puzzle serves as a microcosm of our current lack of understanding of volatile evolution across much of the solar system. To begin to address these questions, there are three individual, but related, research projects I wish to pursue. 1. The Martian Water/Obliquity Cycle: Further spacecraft observations of the martian surface and subsurface within the next decade will reveal the true extent of water deposits on Mars. Already, the comparative abundances of volatiles on the terrestrial planets and Galilean satellites raise questions, which will only become emphasized in future years. This leads to natural questions about the source of said volatiles. Are they endogenic? Exogenic? And to the following research question… 2. Impact Accretion of Planetary Atmospheres: Recent work has shown that large impacts (10x K/T) may not erode planetary atmospheres, an especially interesting result for Earth in light of conditions likely following the Giant Impact, when the surface and mantle were heavily molten and degassed. This may shed light on how present-day atmospheres were developed both from a total mass and isotopic perspective. These questions about atmospheric chemistry lead to the third research question… 3. Atmospheric Chemistry: Following impacts and volcanic activity, vast quantities of radiatively and chemically active species such as water vapor, CO2, dust and sulfur compounds as well as carbon compounds and other volatiles are injected into the atmosphere leaving their ultimate signature on the surface of a planet. By merging existing climate models with simple models of atmospheric chemistry, we can understand what effect chemistry may have had on putative early planetary climates.


March 2, 2004
The Statistical Upper Mantle Assemblage
Anders Meibom
Stanford University

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*
The notion that the upper mantle is a homogenous, depleted and degassed geochemical reservoir is a fundamental assumption in modern geochemistry, which is implicit in almost all geochemical literature addressing the provenance of mid-ocean ridge basalts (MORB) and oceanic island basalts (OIB), and the evolution of the mantle. I will critically examine this assumption, present isotopic evidence against it, and introduce a new concept, the Statistical Upper Mantle Assemblage (SUMA), which better represents the geochemical state of the upper mantle: a ubiquitous distribution of small- to moderate-scale (i.e. 10^2-10^5 m) geochemical heterogeneity. In the SUMA model, the isotopic compositions of MORB and OIB are the outcome of homogenization during sampling, by partial melting and magma mixing, as predicted by the central limit theorem, and do not require distinct reservoirs or mantle layering. Statistical distributions of diverse lithologic components and sampling theory need to replace the concept of distinct geochemical reservoirs.


March 3, 2004
The Coral and the Moon: Biological Effects in Coral Biomineralization
Anders Meibom
Stanford University

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR: Wednesday, March 3, 2004 at 12:00 noon in E&MS room A340**
Refining and developing coral records of past climatic changes, in order to better understand future climatic changes, is a high-profile scientific endeavor that is currently undergoing a revolution, propelled by scientists equipped with new technologies and a desire to fully understand the coral biomineralization process through a highly inte-gra-ted, interdisciplinary approach. I will present recent advances in our understanding of the biological effects involved in formation of the aragonitic coral skeleton and demonstrate how these processes can affect the precision with which corals can record changes in sea surface temperature. The new data and micro-analytical approaches presented here provide a new tool for investigating the origin, compositional diversity, and evolutionary principles of biominerals.


March 9, 2004
Resurfacing and Tectonics of Ganymede and Europa
Adam Showman
University of Arizona

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*
Ganymede and Europa, two of Jupiter's Galilean satellites, have icy surfaces that display a record of intense resurfacing and tectonics. 65% of Ganymede's surface consists of bright, resurfaced terrain that has defied understanding since its discovery by Voyager in 1979. The best explanation is that bright terrain formed when liquid water or slush flooded a global system of rift valleys, but there has been no mechanism for pumping dense liquid water onto the surface, confining the flows to the rift valleys, or even producing the near-surface liquid water in the first place. To overcome these problems, I describe calculations showing that ancient tidal heating events can plausibly produce near-surface liquid water, and I describe new mechanisms for delivering the liquid to the surface. In particular, I show that topography associated with rift valleys induces subsurface pressure gradients that can drive negatively buoyant liquid water upward into the rift valleys, naturally helping to explain the bright-terrain morphology. Pros and cons of the model will be discussed.
Next I switch gears and discuss portions of Europa's surface that are covered by pits, domes, and disrupted "chaos" regions. A popular hypothesis is that these features result from solid-state convection in Europa's ice shell, but this hypothesis has not yet been fully tested by quantitative physical models. Here I present numerical simulations of convection in Europa's ice shell that shed light on whether convection can produce the observed features. I will discuss the simulations and their implications in detail.


March 10, 2004
Dynamics of giant-planet atmospheres
Adam Showman
University of Arizona

*Co-sponsored by CODEP*

**SPECIAL ADDITIONAL SEMINAR: Wednesday, March 10, 2004 at 12:00 noon in E&MS room A340**
The giant planets exhibit a diverse range of atmospheres that are exotic from the perspective of terrestrial meteorology. In this talk I will provide an overview of atmospheric dynamics on the outer planets and discuss several major unsolved problems that I am investigating. First, Jupiter and Saturn exhibit numerous (>10) east-west jet streams, and despite 30 years of research the origin of these jets remains poorly understood. The two endpoint hypotheses are that the jets result from either (1) convection in the deep interior or (2) turbulent vortex interactions near Jupiter's cloud layer. Neither hypothesis has been sufficiently well investigated, and I am involved in several projects to attack these issues. Second, the wealth of vortex and wave features on the giant planets, and their interactions with the jets, remain poorly characterized. Of particular importance are Jupiter's equatorial dry regions (the "5-micron hot spots"): the Galileo probe entered such a dry region in 1995, and understanding the dynamics of these features is key to unraveling the implications of Galileo probe data for Jupiter as a whole. Furthermore, the varied coherent vortices, turbulent regions, and quasiperiodic convective outbursts that exist on all four giant planets raise numerous problems whose solution can shed light on the general circulation; I will discuss several highlights of my research in this arena. Finally, time permitting, I will summarize the possible circulation regimes of extrasolar giant planets discovered close to their parent stars and the relevance of the circulation for upcoming observations. The overarching theme is to understand how giant-planet atmospheres are similar to -- or different from -- more familiar atmospheres such as Earth's, hence helping to place atmospheric science in a broader context.